The Cambridge Congestion Charge, or Sustainable Travel Zone was a scrapped congestion pricing scheme proposed by the Greater Cambridge Partnership that was scheduled for completion in 2027/28. The scheme proposed a £5 minimum daily charge on vehicles entering the city of Cambridge, increased to £10 for vans, and to £50 for heavy goods vehicles and coaches. Exceptions were proposed for "emergency vehicles, disabled tax class vehicles and breakdown services", among others. The scheme became the subject of local controversy, with 58% of respondents recording their opposition to the scheme in an official consultation, which the GCP believed would help fund transport provision and reduce congestion. It was scrapped in September 2023 after Liberal Democrats blocked progress on the proposals.[1]
Background
Cambridge is a small university city in England, United Kingdom with a population of 145,700 as of the 2021 United Kingdom census.[2] The city is served by two National Rail stations – Cambridge and Cambridge North, with bus links principally provided by Stagecoach including guided busway and park and ride services. In October 2022, Stagecoach cancelled 18 Cambridgeshire bus routes due to "significant falls in passenger numbers" resulting in local backlash.[3] In the 2021 census, just 41% of residents reported to use "private motorised vehicles" as their main means by which they commute to work compared to 49% by cycle or foot, with Cambridge having the highest level of city cycle usage in the UK.[4]
Proposal
Proposals for the Sustainable Travel Zone were first published by the Greater Cambridge Partnership in August 2022, putting forward a planned £5 minimum charge for entering the city of Cambridge by motor vehicle operating weekdays from 7am-7pm.[5] The proposed charge levels were set out at:
| Category | Proposed charge (per day) | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Cars, mopeds, motorbikes | £5 | The GCP has noted the "potential to explore a 50% discount for zero emissions vehicles" |
| Vans, vehicles with more than 9 seats | £10 | Excludes coaches and buses |
| Coaches, HGVs | £50 | |
| Registered buses, taxis, private hire vehicles | Free |
Exceptions were proposed for:[6]
- Emergency vehicles
- Military vehicles
- Disabled tax class vehicles
- Breakdown services
- Dial-a-ride services
- "Certain local authority operational vehicles, e.g. refuse collection vehicles"
- Blue badge holders (up to two vehicles)
- People on low-incomes ("tapered discount 25–100%")
- Car club vehicles
In June 2023, a selection of alternative proposals were put forward for consideration by the GCP board, with further collaboration with Cambridgeshire County Council, after the GCP announced that the proposals should be modified.[7] These included:
- Cars only being charged £5 between 07:00 and 19:00 on weekdays or charging only at peak travel times (in comparison to the previous proposal that placed no exceptions on the times at which the charge would be in force)
- Providing 330 free-days for drivers tiered within the first 4 years of operation
- Exemptions for hospital trips
- Rejecting any Congestion Charging proposal all-together[8]
Response
In response to an official consultation, 58% of respondents recorded their opposition to the scheme, which the Greater Cambridge Partnership believes will raise necessary funds for sustainable transport provision and reduce congestion on the city's roads. Opponents have raised issues related to burdens placed on low income earners, the impact on local businesses and the lack of transport alternatives.[9][10] The proposals have been challenged by the local Labour, Conservative, Liberal Democrat and Green parties, though the local Conservative Party is the only to have definitively rejected any potential congestion pricing scheme outright.[11][12]
It was a major issue in the 2023 Cambridge City Council election.[13]
In July 2023, the Secretary of State for Transport Mark Harper criticised the proposed scheme, calling for the plans to go "back to the drawing board". He accused the Liberal Democrats and Labour of "choosing to pursue an ideological anti-car agenda", stating that they "must listen to local residents".[7]
In October 2023, some councillors on Cambridge City Council discussed how a congestion charging scheme should remain an option for future consideration.[14]
See also
References
- ^ "Cambridge congestion charge plans 'are not going ahead'". BBC News. 2023-09-06. Retrieved 2023-10-18.
- ^ "Population and household estimates, England and Wales: Census 2021 – Office for National Statistics". www.ons.gov.uk. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ "Mayor slams 'unacceptable' cuts as Stagecoach reveals plans to axe 18 Cambridgeshire bus routes". 2022-09-22.
- ^ "Cambridgeshire Insight – Population – Census 2021 – Topic Summaries – Travel To Work". cambridgeshireinsight.org.uk. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ "Greater Cambridge Partnership sets out plans for £5 road user charge and bus network shake-up with £1 fares". Cambridge Independent. 2022-08-26. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ a b "Making Connections presentation 07 11 22" (PDF). Greater Cambridge Partnership. 2022-11-07. pp. 9–10.
- ^ a b "Cambridge congestion charge needs re-examining, says transport minister". BBC News. 2023-07-14. Retrieved 2023-08-01.
- ^ "Cambridge congestion charge plans move ahead but face changes". BBC News. 2023-06-29. Retrieved 2023-08-01.
- ^ "Making Connections 2022 Consultation Report" (PDF). Greater Cambridge Partnership. pp. 55–103. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ "Cambridge city congestion charge plans set to continue". BBC News. 2023-06-08. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ "Local elections 2023: Might congestion charge plan decide Cambridge vote?". BBC News. 2023-04-28. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ Brown, Hannah (2023-04-14). "Political parties on the potential Cambridge congestion charge". CambridgeshireLive. Retrieved 2023-06-15.
- ^ "Local elections 2023: Might congestion charge plan decide Cambridge vote?". BBC News. 2023-04-28. Retrieved 2024-01-23.
- ^ "Future Cambridge congestion charge could be considered". BBC News. 2023-10-18. Retrieved 2024-01-23.